America's Next Author background
Susan Gale Wickes writing contest
Tweets by Susan Gale Wickes

Susan Gale Wickes

"Writing scares me. It's like giving people a glimpse into your soul and hoping they like what they see." Susan Gale Wickes is an aspiring author, born and raised in the midwest. She has won awards in song writing and poetry, but this is her first entry in a short story competition.

Story: Bigger Fish to Fry

Interview

Each week authors will be given a new question to answer which will lend additional insight into their story and writing process. Do you have a question you'd like to see the authors answer? Tweet it to @aNextAuthor!

Q:
What is the best writing advice you've ever heard?
A:
The best writing advice I've ever heard is to simply write from the heart. If you're not passionate about the message you're trying to convey, the readers will probably sense that and the story won't be memorable.
Q:
When you start a new story do you prepare an outline in advance or do you just jump right in?
A:
I'm afraid I usually just jump right in. Typically, the ideas for my stories come right out of left field and I'm so excited about putting them on paper that I don't take the time to prepare an outline.
Q:
How do you deal with writing criticism, apart from just ignoring it?
A:
I'm trying not to ignore any of the criticism I've received in this competition. This is all new to me and I really appreciate any comments that will help me grow and become a better author.
Q:
America's Next Author has been running for almost 8 weeks. If you could re-submit now, would you change anything about your story?
A:
Yes! After reading reviews for my story, I think I would try to focus more on what the readers want and less on what I want. While I did try to create an air of mystery, I have since discovered that readers really want, and deserve, to know more.

Reviews

Busyfingers

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
I really loved the story, her preoccupation with having Bonnie Rae's approval, and her willingness to do anything the girl said hit home. It was a good read; well done! Like others have said, though, I wished something had been said about 'the guy' early on; crushes really spice things up. It would also be great if there was some sort of faceoff with Bonnie Rae, to show the MC had grown up and was on to more important things. If you can, please check out my story, Double Take, and let me know what you think.

Big Dave

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
An excellent read!!!

Ann Mason

Rating starRating starRating starRating starRating star
This was an exceptionally well-written tale about a young girl trying desperately to find her place in the world. The author did a lovely job with the question--will the main character find her place with the rebel Bonnie Rae, or will she decide to go for a more "normal" existence with the boy at the dance? I agree with some of the prior comments re: foreshadowing the potential romance with a few more mentions of the guy, and I'd also recommend a bit more "showing" and less "telling." Other than that, I found the story both relateable and enjoyable. Nice work!

KendraA

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
I think you have a great gift of storytelling. Keep up the good work! Good luck in this contest and whatever you decide to do in writing.

Snickers

Rating starRating starRating star
I love the idea of the story. I love the voice of the character. You can hear her and it filled me as I was reading. That’s fantastic. I connected right away, great first sentence—I was interested immediately—and I stayed there. That being said, I think you spent too much time in the beginning telling us about how the MC felt when she was with BR. After the introduction and the recollection of painting her fingernails (and the nice touch of how it made the MC feel) I was ready to move on to some action. It’s not that anything you added about their relationship was bad, it just wasn’t necessary, I felt. For example, I didn’t think this sentence: “Strange how she always seemed to get something out of the deal and I was always the one who ended up holding the short end of the stick.” was necessary. You did such a good job painting their relationship that I didn’t need that. Hope that makes sense. Anyway, by that point I’d gotten the gist of the two of them together and was ready for the meat. That’s a GOOD thing. It means you did your job in the paragraphs before. From here I felt a tension building, an escalation as the MC fell deeper in with BR. I just knew BR was going to convince the MC to do something really bad. (Which she did). And I was into it! But I wanted to know the plan! It was going to be “the most exciting adventure of her otherwise boring life.” This was something that was possibly going to land them in the paper or require them to flee the county! That’s major! I wanted the MC to tell BR to shove it and go off with the guy at the end (good for her!), but I needed to know what crazy thing they’d concocted. I felt like I’d been promised something that never came, which, in the end made me sigh and deflate. I did like how you wrapped up the last line though and tied the title in again. Nice way to bring it back around.

M.A.Wakanda

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Susan, your story about fitting in is such an important topic, and this is the type of story that all of our teens should be reading and discussing! Your writing voice appeals to the teenage category, but it is also easy for an adult to read and relate to. I aimed for a younger audience, but I am also hoping to inspire others to be kind. Thank you for your story, and keep writing. Would you mind taking a look at my story? "Missy's New Home" http://www.ebookmall.com/author/maila-adal-wakanda

Margaret Alice

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Your story showcased some important life lessons. It was great how your writing style was able to catch the voice of a young girl. Although your story seemed to hold back in many places. We never learned more about the plan and the girl's crush just appeared out of nowhere. It left me feeling this story was somewhat incomplete. Your story has good potential though! Could you check out my story, "The Fate Continuum?" Good Luck!

JulieNoble38

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Ah the pull to fit in is very strong, not many people manage to resist, in fiction or in life. Your story was a very realistic picture, and in fact could be developed into a novella, with greater explanation of the characters and the mystery plans which were so intriguing. Good luck in the competition, you're high in the ranks so that's exciting!

Tatyana Black

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
I enjoyed reading this but the ending did seem a bit weak. Also, describing a little more in detail the adventures that Bonnie Rae thought up would have made this story more intriguing. Overall a sweet, pleasant story.

M.J. Milner

Rating starRating starRating starRating starRating star
Lovely piece of writing displaying excellent use of internal dialogue and atmosphere. It could easily have been pleasantly longer. Thanks for writing!

Addai Agyemang

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
I liked your story and the concept of it a lot, how when we're young we're always looking to fit in and how hanging with the wrong crowd of people can make or break you during this period, except the main character--at least when she was describing what she did as a sophomore--didn't feel like a high school student. There were incidents, like when she was talking about Bonnie Rae doing her nails, when I thought the narrator was referring to her time in middle school or elementary school. Having said that however I found myself more interested in Bonnie Rae's character than the narrator, and not in a bad way either. The fact that the narrator is so invested in Bonnie Rae makes me as curious and intrigued with the character Bonnie Rae herself. However I wish that you'd allowed the narrator to discover her own self worth without the help of a guy, especially a seemingly random one whom she had never previously mentioned in the story. I feel that it detracts from the overall them of the story, at least the theme I felt was being conveyed, that only individuals can decide their own self worth. I feel that if you'd allowed the narrator to discover herself that she didn't need Bonnie Rae's friendship to have a sense of self worth, then the message would have come across better. On another note, as I said I really liked the concept of your story and the narration. I felt that I was sitting in a room with an older woman telling me an antidote about her experiences and that aspect was really immersive. The only other thing I would say you might want to add is more descriptions of things. Other than that it was a good story and I enjoyed reading it. :)

Vanessa Carrera

Rating starRating starRating star
I really thought that history would lead me somewhere else, I was so focused on the character of Bonnie that the end has left me a little cold. I understood the message, the transition from adolescence, wanting to fit in some way but I expected to happen something momentous with her friend to get to that point!

incitetowrite

Rating starRating starRating star
I like that you got at that teenage desperation that (mostly) girls feel when they don't "fit in" quite right. I like the fantasy of her knight in shining armor, so to speak, coming to rescue her from this evil plot at the very last minute. I, too, would have loved to know what insidious deed the girls were planning!

Angelina

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
At first I was a bit unsure as to whether i could get into your story, but it got to me and by the end I was completely engrossed. I really enjoyed the way you stayed true to your character. Good luck to you, I must say this is one of the few times I haven't anything I can further expound upon.

Lisa Rose

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
When you write, sometimes people like it sometimes they don 't; its like a choice between vanilla or chocolate ice cream. This story is my flavor, I liked it. Your character just needed to find her confidence and Bonnie Rae gave it to her. Don't stop writing. If you have the time please read my story, 'Drift Away' and leave a review to let me know if you liked it.

Alyce Wilson

Rating starRating starRating star
This story had a genuine feel to it: I found it easy to believe the narrator and her experiences. It tended towards being episodic, and I would have liked the narrative to have a stronger pathway from beginning to end.

Lori Paris

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Very well written! Great use of imagery. I found myself smiling. It reminded me of Judy Blume! How cool is that??!! I read the other author's comments and I did agree that having the guy mentioned earlier....once or twice....would have been good. I don't agree about knowing "the plan" though. This isn't a book...and I don't think it was about Bonnie Rae McCarthy at all. It was about a young girl stumbling along in adolescence and I found it charming. If I was a young adult I could see reading this again and again! I would make this into a book if I were you!!!

A L Motsy

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
I enjoyed this story. I was just a bit let down that we never learned what the girls had planned to do at the dance though. But, even without learning that, the ending was good. I'm a sucker for happy endings and the girl gets boy thing. Well written and kept me reading from beginning to end!

Kellene Killmer

Rating starRating starRating star
This story had a lot going for it; aside from being well-edited and well-paced, it had compelling characters, intrigue, incredibly relatable internal struggles, and an extraordinary plan that caused our protagonist so much anxiety and built the narrative to a crescendo... only to leave us hanging when we got there. The whole story is about Bonnie Rae and a hunger for connection, and I understand that the synopsis says it's about getting close to the edge and then getting pulled back at the last second, but in this case the reader pulls back as well. We need three things in order to follow you to the end and feel the story is complete. 1: Foreshadowing for "him." Who is he? We don't know he exists or that she has feelings for anyone until the story is nearly over, so her getting him doesn't thrill us, because we didn't know she has wanted him. 2: Even if the plan doesn't come to fruition, we need to know what it is. It gives more weight to the choice made to choose the boy and the dance instead, and doesn't leave the reader wondering where the plot disappeared to. 3: We need resolution for Bonnie Rae. She was the focus of most of the story, and she and her big plan were abandoned. Even if it is nothing more than an angry look, we need some acknowledgement that the protagonist chose to leave her behind and that Bonnie has feelings about that. Overall it's well-conceived and the writing is strong, but the last few paragraphs take the wind out of the sails of everything leading up to them.

Frances Bell

Rating starRating star
Relate-able but not original. A standard COA story told with good characterization of the two leads. However, I found the ending very weak because it wasn't foreshadowed. The ending needed more context - contrasts between the two types of friendships were essential to build the conflict and therefore drama which was totally missing from this piece. Lots of potential not realized. Sorry.

baggyk

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
This is a very sweet coming-of-age story that has universal appeal. Sometimes, an orphaned child can be saved from certain disaster and we all deserve that hope. I wonder how that rescue happened, but while I was reading, I was completely involved.

anonymous

Rating starRating starRating star
I liked this story because it realistically displayed the characters and you could see them as real people. However, your story left me wanting more . . . and not in a good way. The biggest problem I had was that you kept talking about this big elaborate plan. It was so terrifying and crazy that the poor girl was considering plan B - leaving the country. So then, what was this big elaborate plan? I did not like that you did not explain it. I read to the end hoping that they were going to do this wild, crazy thing . . . but they didn’t do it and I never found out what it was. Another thing is that I had to re-read and really think about some parts of your story before I understood it. So I guess there were some flow problems. I did, however, like how you built up this strong bond between the main girl and this Bonnie Rae character, and then at the end tore it apart. I thought that was good, although I can't see her being accepted into the "norm" when she was such an outcast. I thought that was a little unrealistic for a story that seemed so realistic. I liked it though, and I thought the way you ended it gave substance to your story. I also liked that she came out of her shell and kissed the guy. You go girl! In the end, it was a pretty good read.

Summer Beth

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Really enjoyed this story, some parts even had me laughing. It was cute and very well written. The only thing I would critique would be to add more detail in certain places. For example, when describing Bonnie's room you said she had "strange things" and "odd collections"- what kind of strange things? We also don't know much about what the main characters look like or what happened to the main characters mother. Other than that, it was a great read. Wonderful job!

Mrs. T

Rating starRating starRating starRating starRating star
I'm glad I took the time to read this story. Sometimes it's difficult to choose the right path and this story was like a walk down memory lane. Well written and worthy of a vote.

Jill Amber Menard

Rating starRating starRating starRating star
Hi Susan - Our stories are similar in the fact they talk about not fitting in, learning to just be yourself, how a boy trumps everything, etc. I enjoyed reading your story and felt it really pulled me in. I would've liked a bit more description of the main character, what she looked like, knowing her name, etc. I liked the hook of the "big plan" and I like that we never know what it was. The boy did kind of come out of nowhere, but then again they always do! And young love is just so sweet, so powerful, and incredibly distracting. Well done!

Leave a review

You have to be logged in to comment. Log in
Not a great read
Masterpiece
AUTHOR RANK
-
Loading..
DECEMBER 18th 2012
The winner of America's Next Author 2012 has been announced! [...]
DECEMBER 7th 2012
Questions and answers about the Battle Round. [...]
America's Next Author

#ANA2012 | What Fans Have To Say

About

America's Next Author is the first social writing contest. Friends, family, fans and publishing industry experts will read authors' submissions and nominate their favorite to be America's next major author. Everyone can participate!